الدرس 1 من 15
تلخيص درس Active Writing: Evaluating others' views
الدرس باختصار
In a for-and-against essay you do not only list what other people think. You also judge how good each argument is: where it is strong and where it is weak. This makes your essay balanced and mature. التقييم يعني أن تبيّن نقاط القوة والضعف في الحجة.
مصطلحات الدرس
- Perspective
- A way of looking at a topic — وجهة نظر
- Flaw
- A weakness or mistake in an argument — نقطة ضعف
- Valid
- Reasonable and based on good evidence — منطقي ومقبول
- Counter-argument
- An argument against another argument — حجة مضادة
أهم الأفكار
Introduce the view, then judge it
First say who thinks what: Many parents believe that phones harm children's sleep. Then judge it: This is partly true, but it ignores the fact that ... Always show both the view and your evaluation.
Show strength, then weakness
Use a phrase for the good side: This argument is convincing because ... Then a phrase for the weak side: However, it overlooks ... / It is less convincing when we consider that ... A fair essay does both.
Look for typical flaws
Ask: Is there evidence or only opinion? Is it too general (all teenagers, nobody, always)? Does it forget another group of people? Does it only give one example? Name the flaw politely: This is an overgeneralisation.
Keep a formal, careful tone
Use hedging: may, might, tends to, to some extent, in many cases. Avoid insulting words such as stupid or silly. Say the argument is weak, not the person.
أمثلة محلولة
مثال 1: Judging a view
View: 'Online shopping is better because it is cheaper.' Write one sentence that gives a strength and one that gives a weakness.
اعرض الحل
- Find what is true in the view: prices online are often lower.
- Find what it ignores: delivery costs and returns can add money.
- Join them with However.
الجواب: It is true that prices online are often lower; however, delivery fees and returns can cancel the saving.
مثال 2: Spot the flaw
'Everyone my age spends all day on social media, so it is harmful.' What is the flaw?
اعرض الحل
- Look at the words everyone and all day.
- They are extreme and cannot be proved.
- Name the flaw.
الجواب: It is an overgeneralisation: not everyone spends all day online.
مثال 3: Add an evaluating phrase
Complete: 'Some people say video games waste time. This argument is ______ convincing, since many games teach planning skills.'
اعرض الحل
- The writer disagrees with the view.
- We need a negative degree word.
- Use 'not very' or 'less'.
الجواب: Less (This argument is less convincing ...)
أخطاء شائعة
The essay only lists opinions: 'Some say A. Others say B.'
ليش غلط: There is no judgement, so the reader does not know your thinking.
الصح: Add a sentence after each view that says how strong it is and why.
Using very strong words: 'This idea is completely stupid.'
ليش غلط: It sounds rude and not academic, and it is an opinion without reasons.
الصح: Say: This idea is not very convincing because ...
اختبر حالك
1. Complete: 'This argument is convincing. ______, it ignores older people.' (one word for contrast)
اعرض الجواب
الجواب: however
A linker of contrast introduces the weakness.
2. A weakness in an argument is called a ______ (one word).
اعرض الجواب
الجواب: flaw
Flaw means a mistake or weak point.
3. 'All teachers give too much homework' is an example of an ______ (one word, starts with over).
اعرض الجواب
الجواب: overgeneralisation
It uses all to talk about everyone without proof.