الدرس 3 من 14
تلخيص درس How a debate is organised and how to argue
الدرس باختصار
A debate is a structured argument between two teams. Knowing the order of the stages helps you prepare. The proposition supports the statement; the opposition argues against it. المناظرة لها مراحل مرتبة.
مصطلحات الدرس
- Statement (motion)
- The topic that teams argue about — الطرح
- Proposition
- The team that supports the statement — الفريق المؤيّد
- Opposition
- The team that argues against — الفريق المعارض
- Rebuttal
- A reply that shows the other side's argument is weak — الردّ/الدحض
- Counterargument
- An argument against another argument — حجة مضادة
- Evidence
- Facts or examples that support a point — دليل
أهم الأفكار
The order
1) The teams hear the statement and prepare arguments in their groups. 2) The speakers for the proposition and opposition present their main arguments. 3) Speakers from both teams present their rebuttals. 4) The debate is summed up and the winner is announced. Remember: prepare, argue, rebut, sum up.
Good arguments
Think of many arguments first, then analyse how strong they are. Back up your points with reasons, examples or research. Keep to the point and be relevant. Do not exaggerate or use extreme words such as always or never: they make an argument weaker. Stay objective and calm, even if you do not agree personally.
Useful phrases
It is important to realise that ... / The crucial point is that ... / According to research ... / There is some evidence that ... / It is easy to think of examples in daily life. / So, as we have seen, ... therefore we must ... / This clearly shows ...
أمثلة محلولة
مثال 1: First stage
Which stage comes first? Teams hear the statement and prepare / The winner is announced
اعرض الحل
- Before arguing you must know the topic.
- The winner comes last.
الجواب: Teams hear the statement and prepare
مثال 2: Rebuttal
In which stage do both teams reply to each other's arguments?
اعرض الحل
- After the main arguments each side replies.
- That reply is a rebuttal.
الجواب: Rebuttals
مثال 3: Last stage
Which stage is last?
اعرض الحل
- Everything has been said.
- Then the result.
الجواب: The debate is summed up and the winner announced
أخطاء شائعة
The winner is announced before the rebuttals.
ليش غلط: The judge needs all arguments and replies first.
الصح: Rebuttals come before the summing up and winner.
Always and never make an argument strong.
ليش غلط: Extreme words are easy to disprove.
الصح: Avoid always and never.
اختبر حالك
1. Put in order (write the letters): a summed up and winner announced; b main arguments; c hear statement and prepare; d rebuttals.
اعرض الجواب
الجواب: cbda
Prepare, main arguments, rebuttals, sum up.
2. Which stage comes just before the winner is announced? (one word)
اعرض الجواب
الجواب: rebuttals
Rebuttals, then the summing up.
3. Which team supports the statement? (one word)
اعرض الجواب
الجواب: proposition
Proposition = for.
جاهز تتدرّب؟
4 سؤال على هالدرس، بتتصحّح خطوة خطوة، ومعها تلميحات لما تعلق. أول أسئلة مجانية.
تدرّب على 4 سؤال من هالدرس مجانًا